Planet Rugby

XV of the Week: Rugby Championship

17th September 2012 12:58

Aaron Smith congratulated by Richie McCaw

Key to victory: Smith and McCaw

Now that the dust has settled in the southern hemisphere, Planet Rugby looks at the players who stole the show in the Rugby Championship.

15 Israel Dagg (New Zealand) - The All Blacks full-back is the only player to have kept his place in our team since the opening round. And based on Saturday's effort, it's clearly obvious why. Once again, Dagg was as cool as ice under the bombardment of high balls from South Africa, while - not for the first time - showcased his playmaking ability by setting up and scoring the first try.

14 Bryan Habana (South Africa) - The Bok flier reminded everyone just why he was rated the best in the business with his superb solo try that brought his team back into the game. Try of the tournament aside, Habana always ran hard when he got his chance and will be kicking himself for butchering a try-scoring opportunity early in the game.

13 Marcelo Bosch (Argentina) - Took plenty out of Australia's defence with his strong ball carrying, chased kicks with all he had and showcased his distribution skills on attack. Was also rock solid in marshalling the Pumas midfield defence.

12 Pat McCabe (Australia) - Showed he's the answer at 12 for the men in gold after bringing direction and purpose to an often pressurised Wallabies attack, whilst he was also the highest tackler in the backs for Australia. His first-half yellow card didn't prove too costly, and saved a certain try. But went from zero to hero with a crucial touchdown that kick-started Australia's fightback.

11 Digby Ioane (Australia) - The official man-of-the-match had a hard time of it in the first half thanks to some desperate defence from his opposite number opposite Gonzalo Camacho. But when Camacho was replaced, Ioane found more space to work with - the winger's finishing ability and scorching pace proving too much for the Pumas.

10 Juan Martin Hernandez (Argentina) - Gets the nod for a second week running, Hernandez plays such an enormous role in the drive and direction of the Argentina team. The Pumas pivot's tactical kicking game was once again out of the top drawer, as he dictated where on the field the game was played. Was left to rue two missed conversions though from far out on a weekend where all the team's goal-kickers struggled. Other than that though, another impressive display.

9 Aaron Smith (New Zealand) - Only played forty minutes, but made a huge impact when he came on for an out-of-sorts Piri Weepu. Smith was relegated to the New Zealand bench for a breach of team curfew, however his high-energy, try-scoring display off the pine was a big factor in the All Blacks' victory.

8 Kieran Read (New Zealand) - That assist was pretty special wasn't it? From a soon-to-be-mentioned lock's initial break and offload, number eight Read then bettered his team-mates effort by sending the ball out to a supporting Dagg. Read was also his industrious self with tackles and runs thrown in.

7 Richie McCaw (New Zealand) - He copped two cheap shots from Dean Greyling but was his typical professional self during the post-match when asked about the incident. Minutes after the assault, he was chasing down and reclaiming an Aaron Cruden penalty when many others wouldn't have bothered. A top pro.

6 Julio Faras Cabello (Argentina) - Played a big role in getting the Pumas into a winnable position but ended up on the losing side. Cabello - after an all-action 50 minutes - had the legs to stay with replacement back Juan Imhoff and was rewarded with a contentious try. He would trade it for victory.

5 Nathan Sharpe (Australia) - A much more disciplined performance as he showed a cooler head than against South Africa the week before. He came close to scoring when he was put through a gap by Quade Cooper but was held up by wing Gonzalo Camacho. Cue plenty of stick from his team-mates on Twitter.

4 Sam Whitelock (New Zealand) - We felt slightly harsh when overlooking Kane Douglas, who performed strongly on debut for Australia. But Whitelock keeps maturing in an All Black jersey and has skills many locks simply do not have - case in point being that break and offload to Read which led to the try.

3 Owen Franks (New Zealand) - While it was good to see Jannie du Plessis not give away any penalties (Dean Greyling made up for that), Franks once again was a consistent pillar for the All Blacks. It is not surprising that Steve Hansen has felt the need not to tinker at tighthead. Franks is a key cog.

2 Tatafu Polota-Nau (Australia) - It was a toss-up between Andrew Hore and the Wallaby hooker. Adriaan Strauss tried hard but struggled to have an impact (possibly due to the game-plan) while Eusebio Guiñazú was solid if unspectacular. Polota-Nau enjoyed a full game and was a cool head in their comeback.

1 Rodrigo Roncero (Argentina) - For a third straight week, the 35-year-old has made it. We were undecided as he did not perform as well as rounds two and three, but against Australia he played under the knowledge that there was no Marcos Ayerza coming on on 50 minutes. Another workmanlike and canny shift.

Comments

sandal says...

Owen Franks deserves inclusion if only because this is the first time, in any game, I have ever seen him beat a player with the ball in hand. It was either Greyling of Du Plessis whose tackle he beat, and admittedly he was going sideways and not forwards. But every other time I have seen him with the ball in hand he has gone straight to ground at first sight of a tackler.

Sam Whitelock's offload was pretty special. He did another in the opening minutes of the third test against Ireland that was even better. Where do locks get such skills? Speaking of locks, how South Africa miss Matfield. (How we all miss Matfield!) On Saturday, the maul that the All Blacks once found unstoppable was very containable.

Posted 07:23 18th September 2012

sandal says...

@ben7

If South Africa were the dominant team then, yes, PR has erred in selecting only Habana for their team of the week.

But in truth South Africa weren't dominant. Sure, they missed six of eight penalty kicks at goal, but as I demonstrate elsewhere in these threds, none of those penalties came about through their exerting pressure. All of them came about because the All Blacks committed technical misdemeanours.

Imagine Steyn, Steyn and Goosen had converted all those penalties, would that then warrant the inclusion of further Springboks in the team of the week? Of course not.

Posted 07:13 18th September 2012

KiwiLad says...

Ben7, Dominant team??? What was the score again???

Fran Steyn is off to Hollywood to take up a new career.

Posted 06:30 18th September 2012

nzmaoriboy says...

@ben7 What are you smoking, Loose much and feel like a winner?? So Dominant pushed off 2 scrums & 4 line-outs stolen..They were dominant at missing long range penalties is what! he he....All this SA team done was perform a lot better than anyone expected! In saying that Louw or Alberts were my pick for blindside...& thats all! They could probably expect to have more representation when they decide to play a "better" brand of rugby..think this team is missing Du preez,Burger & Bismark...

Posted 06:21 18th September 2012

jmanngod says...

McCaw by himself could win the rugby championship - There simply has never been a better rugby player.

Posted 05:21 18th September 2012

cuw3100 says...

GOOD ONE Trinats2 :)

was wondering what it was in a closed stadium ...

Posted 04:32 18th September 2012

kpe12 says...

Ritchie's is a level above everyone right now.

When Piri got the ball kicked out of his hand and the Bok's flew down the left wing, Ritchie was the first man there (Piri was still jogging), when the forwards for the Bok's got there and they spun it wide Ritchie was the second to last man on the outside putting pressure on Kirchner who made a wild pass to Habana and the try was bombed. The man is a freak to get out there.

The other time in the game that really stood out, when Greyling "cleared" him out. Ritchie didn't get all fired up and start throwing, calm, cool, professional and collected.

Ritchie lives on the edge of the law in the game (all good 7's do), he gets penalized but his manner on and off the field contributes to his success for staying "on side" with the ref's favor.

Posted 03:30 18th September 2012

Trader2 says...

I am not sure where this Bokke domination comes from, they were competitive thats for sure, but dominant, don't think so. I agree that there should be a spot for Louw, otherwise pretty good team - oh apart from two Wannabies in the forwards (only joshing).

Posted 01:17 18th September 2012

dropkick says...

4 from Argentina this week - well deserved. The men from the Pampas have added huge value to the comp. I can't wait for their home games. Bring it on.

Posted 01:14 18th September 2012

Trader2 says...

Let us bow to the mighty wordsmiths, APV1 and daibok very good.

Posted 01:08 18th September 2012

georgesmith says...

R. McCaw and N.Sharpe don't deserve to be in it. The former was caught cheating, again! and the latter is just over-rated, useless is more appropriate because Australia has so many others that can play better than him.

Posted 00:49 18th September 2012

porridge_time says...

Surprise surprise the thin Skinned APV1 on for a Troll.

Posted 00:46 18th September 2012

Trinats2 says...

Ramage:

You saw me on TV too !!!

Posted 23:37 17th September 2012

MacTavish says...

The Habana try was class. A Skill not many have. But he loses his spot for me as he is a Cheat. This is 2012, not 1972. High Def replays on EVERYTHING. The fact that he handled a ball with both hands that went out, he then convinced the Line Judge he never touched the ball to secure a Line Out back in the NZ 22. Deliberate and Dishonest. Or in one word CHEAT. I used to think he was a Great Sportsman. No more.

Posted 22:25 17th September 2012

Martinmarais78 says...

What about Morne Steyn, PR?

Daibok, you must have spent the afternoon working on you APV post... Pointless, boet, rather drive your London bus!

Posted 22:10 17th September 2012

Missionary says...

In fairness I would have had Vermuelen in at 8. The irony is that Habana getting - and rightly so, when the Bok backs are just pants. They have a redundant game plan and ultimately the AB forwards got on top to win. That illustrates that this isn't the way forward.

Posted 21:27 17th September 2012

2EyedKiwi says...

@Trinats4. That ain't spit mate. ;-)

Posted 20:22 17th September 2012

ArmchairGeneral says...

@Ben7: "most likely the writer is a kiwi or stupid. Most likely both". Ho ho ho. That'll be right.

I think they should have left 9 empty.

Posted 18:45 17th September 2012

speedlizard says...

So McCabe gets on the team for good cheating while Ioane gets on for failing to make an impression until his opponent gets subbed off. Nice one!

Posted 17:25 17th September 2012

APV1 says...

@ melkdave - Flo wears 6, but plays 7. It's those confounded Saffas getting it all muddled up again. But PR plays a little fast-and-loose with the numbers to suit the XV, so I'd have him in at 6 as well. And I couldn't honestly leave out Richie.

Posted 17:10 17th September 2012

Page 2 of 3

Character Count : 0/1900

  • Rugby Championship Fixtures
Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Rugby Championship
Saturday , August 17
Australia vs New ZealandTBC
South Africa vs ArgentinaTBC
Saturday , August 24
Argentina vs South AfricaTBC
New Zealand vs AustraliaTBC
More Rugby Championship fixtures
  • Rugby Championship Table
League
Rugby Championship Table
PosTeamPPts
1New Zealand626
2Australia612
3South Africa612
4Argentina64