New Zealand remains undefeated in the Rugby Championship after defeating a spirited Argentina 21-5 in Wellington. Now it's time for Planet Rugby to rate the players.
15 Israel Dagg: Safe under the high ball when it flew in his direction, but found wanting sometimes at the back when it didn't thanks to some brilliant tactical kicking from Juan Martin Hernandez. Quite a handful on attack though. 6.5/10
14 Cory Jane: Hardly featured in the first half as there was more action on Savea's flank, but came out of his shell after the break as he went looking for work before the ball came looking for him after taking a long floating pass from Aaron Cruden to touch down in the corner. 7/10
13 Conrad Smith: His contribution was obvious as he attacked hard, and was more evident as the game progressed, showing his consistency throughout as Smith set up Savea's try after drawing in three Pumas' players before offloading to Nonu. 8/10
12 Ma'a Nonu: Coughed up possession that led to Argentina's opening try, and put a pass down when NZ were hot on attack in the first half. Recovered in the second half though, showing his usual power with ball in hand. Unselfishly put in Savea when he could have gone over himself. 6.5/10
11 Julian Savea: A menace on attack out wide, Wellington's golden boy also bagged fourth try in the black jersey to give his team some breathing space. 7/10
10 Aaron Cruden: Missed a few shots at goal and spilled the pill on a few occasions. Lacked Super Rugby flair that put him head and shoulders above the rest. Not his best game by a long shot. 5/10
9 Aaron Smith: Fairly anonymous and got ruffed up a few times by the Pumas pack. Subbed half-way through the second half. 5/10
8 Kieran Read: Reasonably solid throughout, showing power with some punishing runs. But was also guilty of butter hands. 7/10
7 Richie McCaw (c): Proved he was human with a few dropped passes in the first half, but came back strongly after the break to lead from the front. 7/10
6 Victor Vito: Blew a golden opportunity to score on the stroke of half-time, but got hauled into touch. Other than that, didn't really put a foot wrong, but taken off at the start of the second half. 6/10
5 Brodie Retallick: Put in a few solid runs but played in the shadow of his second-row partner. Made way for Whitelock in 65th minute. 5/10
4 Luke Romano: Pic of the All Blacks forwards and completely justified his coach's selection by putting in - what we felt - was a man-of-the-match performance. 8/10
3 Owen Franks: Was on the receiving end of some big tackles, and went backwards a wee bit in the scrum. 6.5/10
2 Keven Mealamu: Found his jumpers in tricky conditions, but could not keep Rodrigo Roncero out when defending the tryline. Made way for Hore in the 50th minute. 5.5/10
1 Tony Woodcock: One of his least memorable games in the black jersey. Huffed and puffed but couldn't blow the Pumas' scrum down. 4/10
Replacements:
16 Andrew Hore: Conceded a penalty on a defensive line-out, but added some physicality to the breakdown when he came on. 5/10
17 Charlie Faumuina: Got a run in the final eight minutes for his first All Blacks cap.
18 Sam Whitelock: Whitelock got 15 minutes off the bench after Retallick was preferred to start. Conceded a penalty.
19 Liam Messam: Came on three minutes into the second half for Vito and made a telling impact. Played himself into next weekend's starting line-up. 7/10
20 Piri Weepu: Allwed the All Blacks to control the game a bit more when he come on - certainly proved his doubters wrong. 7/10
21 Beauden Barrett: Five minutes - not enough time to warrant a rating.
22 Ben Smith: Also got five minutes off the bench...






Comments
Ferdie says...
Hakaboogie re Romano. Won all of his nine lineouts, as did Read (7). They also stole 5 from Arg. Romaon 12 runs, 72m only 3 backs did more. 72 is double the highest m run from Arg - Comacho (36). Not bad in only his fourth test.
Posted 07:38 10th September 2012
passtheball says...
Aweblax - you are actually agreeing with my comments except you are adding the rest of the starting team. Read is always rated highly regardless of performance and Romano looked shell shocked at times IMO.
Posted 14:38 09th September 2012
tweedledee49 says...
A bit too generous with the ratings here.
Messam was the only player in my opinion who deserves a high rating and Weepu...
Posted 10:23 09th September 2012
makemehappy says...
Carter was missed. Cruden a little lost in such tricky conditions.
Posted 10:10 09th September 2012
AWEBLAX says...
@passtheball disagree with your comments re Read and Romano the editor rated the whole damn starting team too high and the replacements too low, the guys have to do alot better then this against the Boks, who lift to another level when playing the ABs, but to Argentinas credit they came out swinging.......
Posted 03:36 09th September 2012
ruckingkiwi says...
Romano did play well, despite the heavy hits he put his hand up to truck the ball up the middle, hit rucks, won his lineouts and the scrum was very even I thought.
Posted 02:15 09th September 2012
Hakaboogie says...
Romano was rubbish, several wasted opportunities because of bad passes, often stopped dead in his tracks by excellent Argentinian defense. Aaron Smith didn't have his best game, saw it a few times in the Super comp, a lack of composure when the pressure is on. Weepu showed why he is still an All Black. Messam awesome when he came on, Conrad Smith is all class. Savea not brutal enough, Bring back Hosea!
Los Pumas get there attack going they will be a very difficult team to beat.
Posted 23:28 08th September 2012
mooloonaki says...
yeah the ratings dont make sense. You must have been watching a different game. Argentinas defence was very impressive, they had parity in the scrums, solid in lineouts but they will need to work on their attack and not rely on putting up a high kick and hoping. All blacks still making mistakes but there intent is good and when they play with control and pace no-one can live with them.
Posted 22:00 08th September 2012
passtheball says...
The replacements were the key to a better second half and needed higher marks plus the Argentinians ran out of steam due to the effort on the first 60. Dagg is showing he is no Mils while Read and Romano are too high.
Posted 17:16 08th September 2012
dangerous says...
I didn't see Romano getting 8 out of 10. He got knocked backwards many times by the pumas. Aaron Smith wasn't very well protected at ruck time. Few dodgy hands knocking it about. Difference was weepu new how to deal with it. Low marks all round attributed to Argentinian defense. Argentina were much more aggressive and won the collisions of the first half.
Posted 16:15 08th September 2012