Planet Rugby

South Africa

South Africa

Rugby Championship: XV of the Week

10th September 2012 15:28

Juan Martin Fernandez Lobbe

Fernandez Lobbe: Pumas skipper reaching new heights

Now that the dust has settled in the southern hemisphere, Planet Rugby looks at the players who stole the show in the Rugby Championship.

15 Israel Dagg (New Zealand): Toughest position to fill considering there were no real standouts in the number 15 jersey. But Dagg gets the nod due to the horrendous weather in Wellington which caused the power cut that plunged the stadium into darkness. Swirling 160km/hr winds and rainy conditions are normally a full-back's nightmare, however Dagg did pretty well under the circumstances.

14 Cory Jane (New Zealand): Didn't get his hands on the pigskin too often in the first half, but came to the party in the second forty for New Zealand and wrapped up the result with a well deserved try. Mention too for Bryan Habana - execution and consistency has been a problem for South Africa, but the same can't be said of the veteran winger who showed he still has an eye for the tryline before limping off with an ankle injury.

13 Conrad Smith (New Zealand): The pick of New Zealand's backs as the Wellington local straightened the All Blacks attack and tried his best to create chances that usually ended in frustration. A classy touch from the returning Smith enabled partner in crime Ma'a Nonu to put Julian Savea over for a crucial five-pointer.

12 Berrick Barnes (Australia): His kicking was questionable in general play, but from the tee he was outstanding and potted six from six thanks to his unerring boot for a personal haul of 16 points. Barnes was no slouch on defence either, and put in the majority of hits in the Wallabies' backline (9).

11 Julian Savea (New Zealand): Try aside, his work rate was miles ahead of what he produced in his last start for New Zealand (against Ireland in Christchurch in June) and may have done enough to secure a start against South Africa on Saturday.

10 Juan Martin Hernandez (Argentina): A defensive rock for the Pumas (just ask Conrad Smith), while his tactical kicking was out of the top drawer - using clever low grubber kicks to turn around the All Blacks back three. Put opposite number Aaron Cruden under constant pressure as the All Blacks playmaker was made to look very ordinary indeed.

9 Will Genia (Australia): Put in a polished and assured performance before he was forced off the field with 11 minutes to go as Australia's captain's curse struck again. Mention too for New Zealand replacement Piri Weepu who added a bit of mongrel around the ruck and allowed the All Blacks to control the game a bit more in the final quarter.

8 Juan Martin Fernandez Lobbe (Argentina): Argentina were well led once again by their bustling, bristling number eight who is without a doubt the heartbeat of their pack. An inspirational performance, that saw the Pumas skipper lead the way on defence with 15 tackles and was also a handy option at line-out time. Mention too for Wallabies super-sub Scott Higginbotham who broke a 178 minute try-scoring drought when he burst through just two minutes after coming onto the field for Radike Samo in the second half.

7 Michael Hooper (Australia): Australia's out-and-out fetcher translated his Super Rugby form to the Test stage and proved that he belongs at this level after a busy day at the office for the Wallabies. Hooper topped Australia's tackle chart (11 hits), whilst he also put in the hard yards with ball in hand.

6 Marcell Coetzee (South Africa): Robust and resilient, Coetzee has taken to the Test arena like a duck to water. The more comfortable he gets, the more physical attributes he brings to the game as the Bok rookie dominated the collisions and tackled like a demon (also 11 hits). But his impact was sorely missed when strangely subbed by coach Heyneke Meyer. Mention for New Zealand's Liam Messam - another superb super-sub who played an impressive 40 minutes off the bench.

5 Sitaleki Timani (Australia): Awarded the official man-of-the-match gong and rightly so, as the big Tongan-born powerhouse continued his solid run of form for the Wallabies. The 25-year-old has been a revelation this season, and it's no wonder Timani's team-mates believe he is on his way to becoming a world class lock. Mention too for Pumas pair Patricio Albacete and Manuel Carizza, however a misfiring line-out didn't help their cause.

4 Luke Romano (New Zealand): Topped the line-out count (nine) and, along with Richie McCaw, was the most effective ball carrier. Although he was the best Kiwi forward statistically against Argentina, it was clear he relishes the confrontational aspect of the game at the highest level.

3 Ben Alexander (Australia): Not only did the prop score an inspirational late try to lift Australia to a crucial win, but also quelled the Springboks' power source - their scrum.

2 Adriaan Strauss (South Africa): Another position that left us scratching our heads. In the end, we felt South Africa's stand-in first-choice hooker performed his core duties effectively enough without being spectacular.

1 Rodrigo Roncero (Argentina): Showed there's still plenty of rugby left in his 35-year-old legs after the veteran front-rower powered over for the game's opening try in his 51st Test. Roncero received the hugs and kisses of a champion when he took a seat with half an hour to go.

Compiled by Dave Morris

Comments

Trader2 says...

Despite Trinats2 above post that he "had moved on" from that story he did respond to it on another post, is he confused or are their two Trinats2's. Anyway this was his comment on the Oz S15 makeup:

"No, we don't have the numbers as you kiwis or saffas to support 5 teams, maybe 4.

But I don't care too much for the other four teams !!! "

Well I did say he needed to think about it and this just about put Oz rugby in perspective, self interest. I cannot speak for SA but in NZ the provinces work together to produce the AB's, in Oz the attitude personified by Trinats2 prduces the rabble that is the current Wannabies. There is no vision in Oz I am afraid. Good thinking Trinats2 - 10 more years.

Posted 15:09 14th September 2012

Trinats2 says...

Trader2:

Sorry mate moved on from that story, are you ok, do you need a cuddle ?? I'll reply to it if it makes you feel better !!!

Posted 12:45 14th September 2012

Trinats2 says...

LOL

Posted 12:43 14th September 2012

APV1 says...

@ ruckingkiwi - pmsl!

Posted 10:04 14th September 2012

ruckingkiwi says...

Trinats, grown men should never use "LOL" to describe their feelings, ever.

Posted 05:12 14th September 2012

Trader2 says...

Trinats2

Refer the "Genia out for 6 months story" still waiting a comment. I appreciate it may be a little difficult for you because you would have to think!

Posted 15:04 13th September 2012

Trinats2 says...

Retardtoo:

"real issues" ??? I was replying to Kiwilad's jibe !

Posted 11:23 13th September 2012

Trader2 says...

Trinats2

Still trolling but no comment on the real issues!!!!

Posted 14:45 12th September 2012

Trinats2 says...

KiwiLad:

LOL.

Only 5 on here ! what about the rest of the kiwis ?? At least the Aussies (Horwill, Pocock, Palu, Moore, Kepu, O Connor, Turner, Mitchell, Geina etc etc etc) are not on there because they're injured !!!

Posted 11:36 12th September 2012

KiwiLad says...

Trinats, why so many Kiwis?? They are just backing winners

Posted 10:46 12th September 2012

georgesmith says...

M. Hooper has been excellent. This is the same player whom R .Deans did not want to give any chance. Based on form, M. Hooper is the Wallabies best no.7. L. Gill is second and D. Pocock is third, also over-rated. I hope D. Pocock can improve. A smart coach will consider playing him at no.6. R. Deans has no vision. S. Higginbottom is not a bench player. D. Dennis and N.Sharpe are not suitable for Test level. B. Barnes doesn't deserve a spot in the team. Too much aimless kicking.

Posted 00:06 12th September 2012

Rude_80 says...

@Ferdie

The ten runs from Savea are because he plays in the Abs, which is pretty easy for a win when his team have a constant open and dynamic game while if you are a wing in the pumas team, you are lucky if a ball comes to you once so as a wing, Camacho has to find work to do instead to be at the corner waiting for a ball to come to him.

Posted 23:52 11th September 2012

PAMPA says...

so smart...

APV1 says...

M - essam

E - tzebeth

D - agg

I - oane

O - rlandi

C - oetzee

R - oncero

E - veryone else

Posted 17:32 11th September 2012

PAMPA says...

ArmchairGeneral

"Think Ozzies will beat Argies as comfortably as ABs did..." jajaja what the hell you talking about...what game did you see...

Posted 16:19 11th September 2012

APV1 says...

M - essam

E - tzebeth

D - agg

I - oane

O - rlandi

C - oetzee

R - oncero

E - veryone else

Posted 16:15 11th September 2012

Trinats2 says...

Who writes this crap

"5 Sitaleki Timani (Australia):"

Sitaleki plays at 4, Sharpe at 5 !!!

Also Dom Shipperly had a very soild game and got over the advantage line against the No3 ranked team and not the No8 ranked team in the world !!! Barnes kept kicking the ball away ???

"2 Adriaan Strauss"

He was in reverse most of the game, as was the saffa pack..

Can't believe there are so many Kiwis in this team !!!

Posted 14:44 11th September 2012

olepete says...

PR you will persist in patronising Argentina. C'mon, they're quite able to stand up for themselves and take criticism.

Posted 13:15 11th September 2012

kinsman says...

So for a view against the majority.... ;-) I obviously stand to be proved wrong but feel that Australia will actually win comfortably against Argentina.

Argentina have a very good defensive game which has to date only been tested by an identical type of team (SA) and in conditions that precluded open rugby (NZ)

The Australian pack showed on Saturday, for all it's doubters, that it could stand up to and in places better the SA pack. Given parity up front and a dry track, the natural attacking instincts of an Australian backline that is long overdue a performance may well appear.

Whilst Genia is a loss there is no doubting the talent available to a backline that can leave Kurtley Beale warming the bench.

A quick check on the forecast shows Saturday expecting 21 degrees and dry.....So..... assuming that the pitch is firm and the forecast correct, I think Australia may well get the 4 try bonus and a c. 20 point margin.

Posted 12:46 11th September 2012

theGadflY says...

@Ferdie- if u want to compare take the average running meters,then u'l realise that camacho hd bettr running meters than savea.

Posted 11:53 11th September 2012

Mace says...

I was at the ABs game. Jane done the haka like an absolute poofter that alone should not of got him in the XV. Cruden got out played by his opposite. I think Romano passed the ball to the touch judge. I love my team but they better perform better this weekend if they want to wrap this Rugby Championship up....

Posted 11:12 11th September 2012

Page 1 of 2

Character Count : 0/1900

  • South Africa Fixtures
Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Rugby Championship
Saturday , August 17
South Africa vs ArgentinaTBC
More Rugby Championship fixtures
  • Table
League
Rugby Championship Table
PosTeamPPts
1New Zealand626
2Australia612
3South Africa612
4Argentina64